Training for criminal defence lawyers and accredited police station representatives: Representing victims of domestic abuse accused of offending
Overview and background to training programme
About the training programme
We have developed this training programme for criminal defence and prison lawyers – both barristers and solicitors – on representing victims of domestic abuse who find themselves accused or convicted of offending. We identified the need for the training through research into the failings in law and practice that can lead to suspects/defendants not being identified as victims and/or their experience of abuse not being properly taken into account in criminal justice decision-making.
The training sessions are accompanied by toolkits accessible to participants in a password-protected area of our website, and our series of short films featuring the experiences of five survivors with lived experience of criminalisation which are freely available here.
Why we developed the training programme
Over the past thirty years CWJ’s director, Harriet Wistrich, has been at the forefront of challenging convictions of women who have killed their abusive partner while subject to coercive control and other forms of domestic abuse. Through our legal advice and casework service, we also regularly receive referrals from women facing prosecution for a wide range of alleged offending resulting from their experience of domestic abuse and other forms of VAWG and exploitation.
CWJ recently undertook a major piece of research considering the barriers to justice for women who kill their abuser. Although the focus of that research is on the small number of women who kill, it also sheds light on the criminal justice system’s ability to deliver justice more widely for those who offend due to their experience of abuse. Our 2022 Double Standard report collates evidence of unjust criminalisation of victims of domestic abuse and other forms of VAWG for a range of offences. The report draws on case studies from CWJ’s legal enquiries service, and earlier research, to explain the barriers to justice faced by victims throughout the criminal justice process. Our subsequent No Safe Space report focuses on the approach taken by agencies in the West Midlands and lessons that can be drawn nationally.
Our research highlights the crucial role played by criminal defence lawyers and police station accredited representatives in ensuring domestic abuse is properly taken into account in proceedings against victims accused of offending, and the need for training. We have therefore developed this training with a range of experts, in order to build the expertise of lawyers and accredited police station representatives working in this area. The following topics are covered in the training:
Domestic abuse, victims’ offending and a trauma-informed approach
At the police station
Crown Court proceedings
Parole and recall
Representing Black, minoritised and migrant women
Challenging prosecution decisions and Magistrates’ Court proceedings
Defences (homicide)
Defences (non-homicide)
Appeals
Credits and acknowledgements
This training programme was written and delivered by a range of experts. Our thanks go to the women who agreed to provide anonymised summaries of their cases, and to take part in training sessions, to help illustrate the systemic problems we are seeking to address.
Session Resources
-
Toolkits
Slides
Session Recording
Click here to watch -
-
-
-
We recommend lawyers working in this area also consult the following relevant training materials:
Inns of Court College of Advocacy (ICCA) training on Advocacy and the Vulnerable (Crime)
Youth Justice Legal Centre training and toolkits, including the Trauma Informed Lawyering toolkit
The Advocates’ Gateway: practical, evidence-based guidance on communicating with vulnerable witnesses and defendants
Howard League for Penal Reform Guide for Anti-racist Lawyers